On Timothy Geithner

Tim Geithner should be the Secretary of the Treasury, because he saved Goldman Sachs;
Tim Geithner should not be the Secretary of the Treasury, because he saved Goldman Sachs;

Tim Geithner should be the Secretary of the Treasury, because he saved Goldman Sachs under a Republican president;
Tim Geithner should not be the Secretary of the Treasury, because he is now serving a Democrat president;